DEV Community

Cover image for My First BugSigDB Contributions Mistakes, feedback, and lessons learned
𝐁𝐚𝐛𝐢 ✨
𝐁𝐚𝐛𝐢 ✨

Posted on Edited on

My First BugSigDB Contributions Mistakes, feedback, and lessons learned

When I started contributing to BugSigDB, I knew I would be working with scientific literature and organizing microbial findings into a structured database.

What I didn't fully appreciate was how much interpretation the work would require.

Although I had a background in Data Science and experience with academic research, microbiome curation introduced new challenges. I had to understand experimental comparisons, microbial abundance, statistical findings, taxonomy, and scientific terminology.

Here are some lessons from my first contributions.

1. My First Contribution: The Mini-Curation

My first task was the introductory mini-curation through GitHub issue #94.

The exercise involved comparing the gut microbiome of individuals living with HIV against individuals without HIV.

One of my first challenges was an ontology issue. The HIV-related term EFO:0000764 was obsolete, so I had to investigate its replacement, MONDO:0005109.

This introduced me to the importance of checking ontology terms rather than assuming that the terminology in a paper is always current.

My mini-curation was accepted, and I moved on to full studies.

2. My First Full Study: Getting Abundance Directions Right

Effect of prophylactic dextrose gel on the neonatal gut microbiome

This study examined neonatal gut microbiota, including comparisons involving delivery mode and feeding practices.

One mistake I made was mixing up the increased and decreased taxa in the delivery-mode comparison.

I had to revisit Supplementary Material 4, which contained the MaAsLin2 results, and correct the directions.

I also learned to distinguish the microbiome study's observational cohort design from the larger randomized trial it was nested within. My mentor, Chloe, emphasized choosing the best-fitting study design rather than selecting multiple descriptions.

My takeaway: Always verify which group has increased or decreased abundance, and understand the actual design of the analysis you are curating.

3. Learning to Extract Findings from Figures

The In Vivo Effect of Water-Based Lubricants on the Vaginal Microbiome of Women from Varying Age Groups

I worked on comparisons involving menopausal status and age, using Figures 3C and 3D to identify microbial findings.

This study helped me become more comfortable extracting information directly from figures rather than relying only on the written Results section.

For example, the findings included lower Lactobacillus abundance in the postmenopausal group.

My takeaway: Figures and supplementary materials are important sources of curation information. Don't overlook them.

4. Understanding Statistical Findings and Conditions

Association of Vaginal Microbiota With Signs and Symptoms of the Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause Across Reproductive Stages

I initially used the condition "postmenopausal atrophic vaginitis" but changed it to "atrophic vaginitis" after reviewing the terminology.

I also spent time understanding odds ratios, confidence intervals, and p-values. In particular, I learned to consider whether a confidence interval includes or excludes 1 when interpreting an odds ratio.

My takeaway: Statistical results and condition labels require careful interpretation. Don't simply copy what you see without understanding what it represents.

5. Distinguishing Differential Abundance from Correlation

Characterization and correlation of gut microbiota in major depressive disorder patients with suicidal ideation

GitHub Issue: #2133
View BugSigDB curation

This study examined gut microbiota in people with major depressive disorder, including comparisons involving participants with and without suicidal ideation and healthy controls.

One important distinction was between differential-abundance findings and correlation analyses.

A bacterium being correlated with a depression score does not automatically mean it is significantly more or less abundant in a particular comparison group.

I had to keep these different types of findings separate when identifying the relevant microbial signatures.

My takeaway: Not every statistical association reported in a paper is a differential-abundance finding. Understanding the analysis is essential.

7. The Biggest Lessons from My First Contributions

Looking back at these experiences, there are several lessons I keep returning to.

Read the supplementary materials

Some of the most important information I needed was not in the main text.

Supplementary tables helped me identify microbial taxa, verify abundance directions, and understand the statistical analyses.

Do not stop at the abstract or even the Results section. Check the supplementary materials whenever the paper refers to them.

Understand the comparison before recording the signature

Always know which group is Group 0 and which is Group 1.

A signature is meaningful only when its direction is correctly associated with the comparison.

Do not confuse different types of statistical findings

Differential abundance, alpha diversity, correlations, and associations are not interchangeable.

A paper may report all of them, but each answers a different question.

Pay attention to taxonomic resolution

Microbial names can be reported at different taxonomic levels.

A finding reported at the genus level should not be casually converted into a species-level entry. Similarly, an ASV or an unclassified taxon requires careful interpretation.

Use the appropriate taxonomy resources and follow the Curation Policy.

Feedback is part of the contribution process

Receiving corrections does not mean you have failed.

In fact, some of my most useful lessons came from reviewing feedback, revisiting the paper, and understanding why a particular entry needed to change.

The goal is not to defend every decision you make. It is to produce an accurate curation.

Keep track of your decisions

As you work through a paper, record where you found important information.

Was it in Figure 2? Supplementary Table 4? The Methods section?

A screenshot from my study notes with several important facts highlighted Figure 1: A screenshot from my study notes with several important facts highlighted

Keeping track of these sources makes it easier to verify your work and explain your decisions during review.

8. Final Thoughts

My first BugSigDB contributions taught me that scientific data curation is much more than transferring information from a paper into a database.

It requires reading carefully, interpreting research methods, understanding statistical results, identifying microbial taxa, and making decisions that preserve the meaning of the original research.

I made mistakes. I received feedback. I corrected my work. I also had the opportunity to collaborate with another contributor and learn from the experience.

What I appreciate most is how each study introduced me to a slightly different challenge. One taught me to pay closer attention to abundance directions. Another made me more comfortable interpreting figures. Others helped me understand study design, statistical findings, taxonomy, and collaboration.

I came into this project with a Data Science background, but I am leaving these early contributions with a much better appreciation of the work involved in making scientific findings structured, searchable, and reusable.

And perhaps the biggest lesson is this:

You do not have to get everything right on your first attempt. You do have to be willing to investigate, learn from feedback, and correct your work.

That is how you become a better curator, one study at a time.

Happy curating!

Top comments (0)