DEV Community

IdleCultivation
IdleCultivation

Posted on

Idle game design notes: one recipe that paid for itself

Development covered 2 Oct 2026 to 3 Oct 2026 (commit dates).

Two days of commits folded into this window, and they sort into three piles: one arithmetic correction, a batch of quest sentences that assumed a past the player never lived, and the Cultivation page growing a purchase card. I will take the arithmetic first, because idle game design lives and dies on loops, and this one was printing money.

Myriad Immortal Sect, the game this devlog is about. Play it free in the browser

The cheapest loop in the Medicine Valley

Six pill recipes sit exactly on the 0.40 craft ratio floor. A disciple of Medicine King Valley buys their inputs 8% under the list price, and once a recipe is mastered the craft succeeds at the 0.99 ceiling. Run the output through the recycle counter and the loop returned 1.076 times the inputs, in stones, on every cycle. Any idle game designer can finish that sentence: a repeatable conversion above 1.0 is a stone engine, and this one ran while the player slept, because buying, crafting and recycling all proceed off tick logic.

The check that watches the economy tested the wrong number. It discounted by each recipe's base success instead of the highest success the recipe can actually reach, so the worst case never appeared in its books and the loop passed for a balanced recipe. It now tests against the ceiling, the recycle rate moves to 0.36, and the worst recipe lands at 0.968, meaningfully below the line where a loop funds itself. The margin is small on purpose. I want recycling a mastered pill to feel nearly free without ever being free.

The Cauldron with its recipes and brewing requirements

Quests that assume your past

The second pile was prose. Chapters 1 to 3 contained sentences that presumed optional quests had been played: the furnace described as the one you bought in a stop the guide treats as optional, a roar in the beast forest that referenced a hunt you might never have taken, Bertram's teahouse promising a meeting nobody attended, and chapter 1 implying you already hold the Foundation Pill you have not been given. Every one of those sentences reads fine if the player took the optional path and reads as a continuity error if they did not, and players who skim side content are not a minority.

The fixes are small, noun-level changes with a large documentation tail: the same corrections propagate through Simplified Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Russian, Vietnamese, Indonesian, Malay, Filipino and Thai, each with its own grammar. A continuity fix that lands in one language and waits in nine is a half-applied fix, so the propagation happened the same night.

A related correction in the same family: a cauldron recipe that the sect join gift is still delivering now says so on its card and offers no Market door, mirroring the craft-card correction from the same days.

A purchase card that opens flat

The third pile is commerce, and the design brief was placement. A player holding an itch download key had to find the unlock page through the profile menu, the shop card or the seal, and none of those surfaces is where a player wonders what the paid edition contains. The Cultivation page now carries a collapsed Complete Edition card from Core Formation onward, and opening it presents the same doors in place: platform picker, key field, the verified-email claim, the website checkout. On the itch build the buy link sits visible on the card without opening anything, pointed at itch's checkout page with the file price filled in.

Two label details cost real time. The have-a-key button wrapped to two lines at phone width, so it is now "I already have a key", measured at 360 pixels and translated in eleven locales. And the gold button says Buy with the price beside it, taken from the catalogue, so the early-bird window shows 4.99 by itself; no price prints until the catalogue answers, because a stale price is a worse lie than an absent one.

The Cultivate screen in phone portrait with its next steps and tribulation button

Tap the card

One last sentence-level fix closes the day. The encounter card said "Choose in 20s" and gave no hint that the card itself opens the choices. A tester playing at phone size let six encounters lapse before discovering the tap. The card now says to tap it, which is the entire fix, and it is my favourite kind: a twenty-second timer was counting down on a door the player did not know opened.

The market panel with its stall tabs and a priced pill shelf

The loop maths above is worth checking by hand if you play a crafter: the alchemy guide explains mastery and the success ceiling, the recipes codex lists the pill recipes on the floor, and the game itself will tell you what a recycle returns at your sect's discount.

Myriad Immortal Sect, the game this devlog is about. Play it free in the browser

Top comments (0)